Browsing: Revisiting

Each offseason as we compile our annual Prospect Handbook, Baseball America staffers take a closer look beyond the top names in each organization. While top 10 prospects often draw the most attention, we also spotlight a handful of under-the-radar players ranked outside their teams’ upper echelon prospects who we believe have the tools, opportunity and momentum to take a significant step forward in the coming year.

These breakout picks are based on a combination of scouting insight, performance trends, player development indicators and conversations with evaluators across the game. These are players who, while not yet household names, could be a strong season away from rising into the national prospect conversation.

Now, with the minor league season nearing its end, it’s time to look back and reassess how we did identifying breakout candidates for 2025.

The stats below were gathered as of Sept. 10, with each player shown alongside their preseason and current rankings. Among the breakout picks, these stood out as the biggest hits:

• David Davalillo, RHP, Rangers
• Bradgley Rodriguez, RHP, Padres
• Jhonny Level, SS, Giants
• Argenis Cayama, RHP, Giants
• Jonathon Long, 1B/OF, Cubs
• Braylon Payne, OF, Brewers
• Rainiel Rodriguez, C, Cardinals
• Payton Tolle, LHP, Red Sox
• Cam Schlittler, RHP, Yankees
• Carlos Lagrange, RHP, Yankees
• Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz, RHP, Yankees
• Khal Stephen, RHP, Guardians (via Blue Jays)
• Yoniel Curet, RHP, Rays

AL WEST

Athletics

Steven Echavarria, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 12
• Current Rank:15
• Stats: 4.59 ERA, 104. IP, 25 GS, 88 SO, 42 BB, 9.3% BB,  19.5%, 37.9 GB%,  4.10 FIP

Josh Kuroda-Grauer, SS

• Preseason Rank: 15
• Current Rank:14
• Stats: .294/.358/.469, 1 HR, 28 2B, 27 SB, 7.3 BB%, 8.8 K%, 100 wRC+

Will Johnston, LHP

• Preseason Rank: 23
• Current Rank: 25
• Stats:4.87 ERA, 68.1 IP, 6 GS, 85 SO, 39 BB, 11.3% BB, 28.9 K%, 43.7 GB%, 4.11 FIP

The Athletics’ farm system has been instrumental in powering their second-half surge in 2025. All three players listed above are key to ensuring that pipeline of talent remains fertile.

Echavarria struggled with his command and strike-throwing early, but he has cut down on the walks and refined his mound presence. The A’s were high on Kuroda-Grauer coming out of the draft, and he’s mostly lived up to his scouting report. Though not known for power, heâ€s displayed excellent contact skills, putting together competitive at-bats and offering consistent production at the plate. Johnston didn’t take a meaningful step forward and was moved to a bullpen role in 2025.

The A’s will get an extended look at both Kuroda-Grauer and Johnston in the Arizona Fall League.

Angels

Trey Gregory-Alford, RHP

• Preseason Rank:12
• Current Rank: 12
• Stats: 2.86 ERA, 78.2 IP, 16 GS, 68 SO, 33 BB, 10.0 BB%, 20.7 K%, 55.1% GB, 4.39 FIP

Dario Laverde, C

• Preseason Rank:15
• Current Rank:NR
• Stats: .214/.289/.292, 4 HR, 13 2B, 0 SB, 7.5 BB%, 22.0 K%, 33 wRC+

Felix Morrobel, SS

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats: .218/.364/.322, 2 HR, 1 2B, 8 SB, 15.3 BB%, 19.8 K%, 91 wRC+

The Angels gave Gregory-Alford an unprecedented $1,957,500 bonus for an 11th-round pick, and so far it looks like for good reason. He quickly emerged as one of the most electric arms in the Arizona Complex League, regularly touching the upper 90s with his fastball and showing improved command as the season went on. Gregory-Alford played a pivotal role in the ACL Angels†championship run as a starter before earning a promotion to Low-A Inland Empire. His mix of power stuff and poise on the mound stood out among his peers.

By contrast, Laverde and Morrobel couldnâ€t quite find their footing, with Laverde struggling in Low-A and Morrobel unable to reach full-season ball despite repeating in the Complex League.

Astros

Ryan Gusto, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 12
• Current Rank:Graduated (Traded to Marlins)
• Stats: 5.67 ERA, 101.2 IP, 17 GS, 97 SO, 36 BB, 7.9 BB%, 24.6 K% 36.9 GB%, 4.62 FIP (MiLB)

Joseph Sullivan, OF

• Preseason Rank: 14
• Current Rank:12
• Stats: .221/.399/.412, 17 HR, 13 2B, 40 SB, 18.5 BB%, 27.4 K%, 78 wRC+

Cole Hertzler, RHP

• Preseason Rank:28
• Current Rank: 29
• Stats:1.13 ERA, 16 IP, 4 GS, 22 SO, 6 BB, 9.4 BB%, 34.4 K%, 50 GB%, 2.13 FIP

After securing the final spot in the Astros†bullpen to start the season, Gusto pitched his way into a starting role for the Astros before he was traded at the deadline to the Marlins alongside infielder Chase Jaworsky and outfielder Esmil Valencia.

Hertzler, a fifth-round pick out of Liberty in 2024, missed the majority of the season due to injury and didnâ€t return until Sept. 3.

Sullivan has elite power and produced some of the best 90th percentile exit velocities in the Astros system. However, his 27.4% strikeout rate has hindered his overall production. Improving his contact rate could lead to more consistent offensive contributions moving forward.

Rangers

David Davalillo, RHP

• Preseason Rank:17
• Current Rank:8
• Stats:2.30 ERA, 101.2 IP, 21 GS, 119 SO, 28 BB, 6.9 BB%, 29.5 K%, 50.2 GB%, 2.74 FIP

Kolton Curtis, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 23
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:5.18 ERA, 66 IP, 16 GS, 75 SO, 44 BB, 15.2 BB%, 25.9 K%, 47.5 GB%, 4.18 FIP

Davalillo picked up right where he left off as one of the most dominant pitchers in the minors. Splitting time between High-A Hub City and Double-A Frisco, he delivered consistent, high-level outings at both stops. Most impressively, he allowed just five home runs all season—even after moving up to the hitter-friendly Texas League. With advanced command, poise and a knack for limiting damage, the 22-year-old has now posted a 2.09 ERA over the past two seasons and continues to rise quickly through the system.

On the flip side, Curtis—an undrafted free agent signed for $125,000 in 2022—has struggled to find the same footing. The 21-year-old flashes promising stuff, but he needs to clean up his control to remain a viable long-term starting option.

Mariners

Tai Peete, OF

• Preseason Rank: 14
• Current Rank: 12
• Stats:.217/.288/.404, 19 HR, 24 2B, 25 SB, 13.7 BB%, 21.6 K%, 79 wRC+

Jeter Martinez, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 15
• Current Rank:26 (Pirates)
• Stats:7.06 ERA, 65 IP, 17 GS, 66 SO, 42 BB, 13.7 BB%, 21.6 K%, 49.7 GB%, 4.37 FIP

Teddy McGraw, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 20
• Current Rank: 17
• Stats:3.18 ERA, 28.1 IP, 12 GS, 33 SO, 8 BB, 6.7 BB% , 27.5 K%, 59.7 GB%, 2.76 FIP

Peete’s power surged with High-A Everett in 2025, where he hit a career-high 19 home runs and stole 25 bases. Pitch selection, however, remains an area for improvement after he posted a high strikeout rate for the second consecutive season. Originally drafted as a shortstop, he transitioned full time to center field, where his athleticism suits him well. Peete produces high-end exit velocities and is still just 20 years old, so time is on his side to refine his approach and cut down on the chase.

Seattle traded Martinez, a 19-year-old Mexican pitcher, to the Pirates at the deadline. The 6-foot-4 righty has big upside and a 99 mph fastball but spotty command of his secondaries. McGraw has big stuff but also two Tommy John surgeries on his ledger. An elbow injury delayed his season this year, limiting him to just 28.1 innings so far.

NL WEST

Diamondbacks

Pedro Catuy, OF

• Preseason Rank: 25
• Current Rank:NR
• Stats:.221/.291/.329, 2 HR, 7 2B, 5 SB, 7.6%BB, 26.6%K, 63 wRC+

Grayson Hitt, LHP

• Preseason Rank: 26
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:4.31 ERA, 64.2 IP, 6 GS, 74 SO, 55 BB, 17.4%BB,  23.3%K, 61.2%GB, 5.13 FIP

John West, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 30
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:5.89 ERA, 99.1 IP, 19 GS, 96 SO, 41 BB, 9.5%BB, 22.2%K, 51.3%GB, 4.76 FIP

All three of these prospects dropped off the Diamondbacks’ list for different reasons. Arizona deepened its system at the deadline after dealing Josh Naylor, Eugenio Suárez and Merrill Kelly, which pushed others down the depth chart.

Hitt spent most of the year pitching out of the bullpen with occasional starts across Low-A and High-A. His fastball sits in the mid 90s, but itâ€s his sharp curveball and slider that have emerged as effective putaway pitches in shorter stints.

West, who stood out in last yearâ€s continuation camp, couldnâ€t find the same consistency this season. He posted a 25.9% called strike rate and a 44% first-strike rate—numbers that suggest better command is needed to stay on a starterâ€s track. Catuy, coming off a knee injury that wiped out his 2024, struggled in the ACL, showing timing issues against velocity and frequent chase.

Rockies

Sandy Ozuna, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 15
• Current Rank: 22
• Stats:1.50 ERA, 6 IP, 1 GS, 6 SO, 1 BB

Cole Messina, C

• Preseason Rank: 20
• Current Rank: 28
• .Stats:.259/.358/.382, 7 HR, 23 2B, 14 SB, 11.8%BB, 16.6%K, 98 wRC+

Kelvin Hidalgo, SS

• Preseason Rank: 21
• Current Rank:23
• Stats:.247/.311/.345, 5 HR, 21 2B, 43 SB, 7.3%BB, 24.7%K, 85 wRC+

Despite pitching just six innings this year, Ozuna remains on the Rockies’ list because of his high ceiling. His 93-96 mph fastball touches 97, though it lacks ideal ride. He may be a candidate to convert to a sinker, which could better suit his profile given his low spin efficiency. His low-80s gyro slider flashes late bite and swing-and-miss potential. A bigger test awaits the 19-year-old in his first full season.

Messina impressed with advanced plate discipline, rarely chasing and showing a low zone whiff rate. That contact-driven approach helps offset his below-average power and gives him a solid offensive floor.

Hidalgoâ€s athleticism and 43 steals for Low-A Fresno stood out. However, his aggressive approach and high chase rate are both concerning. Refining his strike zone discipline will be key to unlocking his offensive potential. Still just 20, thereâ€s time for growth in both his approach and game.

Dodgers

Eriq Swan, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 14
• Current Rank: 14 (Nationals)
• Stats:4.42 ERA, 91.1 IP, 19 GS, 102 SO, 63 BB, 15.8%BB, 25.6%K, 43.6%GB, 4.43 FIP

Brendan Tunink, OF

• Preseason Rank: 19
• Current Rank:17
• Stats:.300/.417/.550, 5 HR, 10 2B, 9 SB, 16.1%BB, 30.4%K, 148 wRC+

Brooks Auger, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 27
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:5.12 ERA, 91.1 IP, 17 GS, 61 SO, 41 BB, 15.3%BB, 10.3%K, 43.1%GB, 4.76 FIP

A promising tuneup in the Arizona Fall League set the stage for a potential breakout year for Swan in 2025. He flashed an electric fastball-heavy arsenal with High-A Great Lakes, though inconsistent command led to occasional blow-up outings. Now with the Nationals—alongside fellow righty Sean Liñán as part of the Alex Call trade—Swan becomes a high-upside project for Washingtonâ€s development staff.

Tunink, an eighth-rounder who signed for $410,000, impressed with his lefthanded bat, showing advanced feel for contact and a steady approach in both the Arizona Complex League and the bridge league. The tools are there, but improved plate discipline will be key to unlocking more consistent production.

Auger still flashes intriguing stuff, but inconsistent command at High-A allowed hitters to capitalize. Heâ€ll need to find more consistency in the zone to make a leap.

Padres

Bradgley Rodriguez, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 13
• Current Rank: 6
• Stats:3.28 ERA, 35.2 IP, 0 GS, 37 SO, 15 BB, 10.3%BB, 25.3%K, 56.3%GB, 3.26 FIP

Kai Roberts, OF

• Preseason Rank: 22
• Current Rank: 27
• Stats:.227/.355/.305, 5 HR, 6 2B, 35 SB, 14.6%BB, 28.0%K, 97 wRC+

Sean Barnett, OF/RHP

• Preseason Rank: 25
• Current Rank: 19
• Hitting Stats:.211/.331/.330, 5 HR, 9 2B, 3 SB, 11.5%BB, 34.6%K, 93 wRC+
• Pitching Stats:21.09 ERA, 10.2 IP, 0 GS, 8 SO, 16 BB, 20.8%BB, 10.4%K, 37.0%GB, 9.03 FIP

After the Padres went all-in at the deadline, there are plenty of opportunities for the prospects remaining in the system to step up as they rebuild their depth. Rodriguez is the most advanced of the group and made his big league debut on May 31. His upper-level experience gives him a head start, but heâ€ll need to stay healthy and continue refining his stuff after returning from a biceps injury.

Roberts has shown a promising hit tool, but itâ€s been overshadowed by swing-and-miss concerns. With a strikeout rate nearing 30% and frequent chasing, his ability to make consistent contact—especially in the zone—remains a key area for growth.

Barnett was developed as a two-way player, but his results were limited on both sides. Narrowing his focus could unlock more consistent progress.

Giants

Jhonny Level, SS

• Preseason Rank: 11
• Current Rank:5
• Stats: .269/.360/.436, 12 HR, 12 2B, 3 SB, 12.3%BB, 17.2%K, 109 wRC+

Josh Bostick, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:3.71 ERA, 119 IP, 23 GS, 139 SO, 39 BB, 7.9%BB, 28.2%K, 37.3%GB, 4.59 FIP

Argenis Cayama, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 29
• Current Rank: 12
• Stats:3.61 ERA, 62.1 IP, 15 GS, 62 SO, 28 BB, 10.3%BB, 22.9%K, 63.9%GB, 4.35 FIP

Level led the Giants’ ACL team, which was among the most talented in the desert. At 18, the 5-foot-10 switch-hitter showed impressive power and consistently used all fields. Though his production dipped in Low-A, the experience positions him well for 2026.

On the mound, Cayama delivered one of the most inspiring turnarounds in the system. After battling pneumonia in 2024, he rose quickly through the ranks, flashing a 92–93 mph two-seam fastball with room for more velocity. His slider is developing into a true out pitch, while his changeup remains a work in progress. Both players are poised to be key contributors in the Giants†pipeline as they continue to refine their tools, while Bostick fell off the Giants’ list

AL CENTRAL

White Sox

George Wolkow, OF

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank: 24
• Stats:.223/.317/.362, 13 HR, 16 2B, 33 SB, 10.9%BB, 29.6%K, 97 wRC+

Blake Larson, LHP

• Preseason Rank: 26
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:Did not play

The boom-or-bust Wolkow again showed some of the loudest exit velocities in the White Sox system along with significant contact questions. The 19-year-old struck out 147 times over 116 games in his return to Low-A, though he actually cut his strikeout rate by over 1 percentage points compared to last year. Wolkow’s penchant for chasing and whiffing limited his ability to consistently tap into his power. Still, the upside is tantalizing if he can refine his approach.

On the pitching side, Larson never got a chance to break out. The 19-year-old underwent Tommy John surgery in January and missed the season.

Guardians

Braylon Doughty, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 12
• Current Rank: 7
• Stats:3.48 ERA, 85.1 IP, 22 GS, 99 SO, 23 BB, 6.4%BB, 27.3%K, 49.4%GB, 2.84 FIP

Juneiker Caceres, OF

• Preseason Rank:21
• Current Rank:26
• Stats:.270/.379/.410, 4 HR, 18 2B, 7 SB, 12.4%BB, 12.1%K, 121 wRC+

Robert Arias, OF

• Preseason Rank: 29
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:.287/.389/.402, 2 HR, 11 2B, 29 SB, 14.6%BB, 11.1%K, 114 wRC+

The 36th pick in the 2024 draft, Doughty took a significant step forward in his first pro season by demonstrating exceptional command of the strike zone. He racked up an impressive 99 strikeouts against just 23 walks, showcasing his ability to consistently pound the zone while maintaining a remarkably low walk rate.

Caceres, meanwhile, finished the season with a 105 mph 90th percentile exit velocity despite only turning 18 in August. He’s an aggressive hitter who manages to stay disciplined at the plate, striking a rare balance between assertiveness and contact without sacrificing quality swings. He could take another step forward as he learns to elevate his best-struck balls more consistently.

Tigers

Owen Hall, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 14
• Current Rank: 26
• Stats:7.00 ERA, 9 IP, 4 GS, 9 SO, 9 BB, 23.1%BB, 23.1%K, 50%GB, 5.99 FIP

Tyler Mattison, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 15
• Current Rank: 17
• Stats:4.72 ERA, 34.1 IP, 1 GS, 37 SO, 28 BB, 18.7%BB, 24.7%K, 31.3%GB, 5.31 FIP

Enrique Jimenez, C

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank: 20 (Twins)
• Stats:.256/.371/.476, 12 HR, 12 2B, 5 SB, 15.6%BB, 22.4%K, 137 wRC+

Hall was more advanced than the typical prep pitcher when the Tigers drafted him in the second round last year, but a stress reaction in his right shoulder limited him to just nine Low-A innings in 2025. Prior to the injury, he boasted a lively four-seam fastball that consistently sat between 94-96 mph, complemented by a sharp 82-84 mph gyro-slider with impressive depth and biting movement.

Mattison had one of the most dominant seasons by a reliever in 2023, showcasing exceptional command and velocity, but he missed all of 2024 recovering from Tommy John surgery. Jimenez set new career highs in home runs and RBIs before being traded to the Twins in the Chris Paddack deal. Since joining Minnesota, Jimenez has hit .269 with 24 strikeouts to 23 walks, showing promise in adjusting to his new environment.

Royals

Ramon Ramirez, C

• Preseason Rank: 11
• Current Rank: 9
• Stats:.249/.335/.445, 12 HR, 13 2B, 7 SB, 10.9%BB, 20.5%K, 116 wRC+

Felix Arronde, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank:16
• Stats:2.80 ERA, 128.2 IP, 24 GS, 101 SO, 42 BB, 8.1%BB, 19.5%K, 41.4%GB, 3.87 FIP

LP Langevin, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 26
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:5.91 ERA, 21.1 IP, 2 GS, 31 SO, 22 BB, 21.1%BB, 29.8%K, 34.9%GB, 4.62 FIP

The Royals already have two promising catching prospects in Carter Jensen and Blake Mitchell, and Ramirez continues to distinguish himself, too. He quickly earned a promotion to Low-A Columbia, where the 20-year-old posted a .781 OPS and 11 homers. Ramirez has elite power potential and high-end bat speed that translates to consistent hard contact.

Arronde, 22, has been a consistent year-over-year performer in the lower levels. The righthander has a solid three-pitch mix that includes a 94 mph fastball, a mid-80s slider and a mid-80s splitter. Langevin, who began the season on the 60-day IL with a lat strain, fell off the Royals’ list.

Twins

Eduardo Beltre, OF

• Preseason Rank:14
• Current Rank: 25
• Stats:.186/.297/.326, 7 HR, 13 2B, 25 SB, 11.6%BB, 24.4%K, 85 wRC+

Payton Eeles, 2B

• Preseason Rank:17
• Current Rank: 24
• Stats:.277/.390/.354, 4 HR, 9 2B, 27 SB, 11.9%BB, 16.7%K, 107 wRC+

Dameury Pena, 2B

• Preseason Rank: 23
• Current Rank:NR
• Stats:.241/.317/.316, 6 HR, 10 2B, 28 SB, 8.4%BB, 8.9%K, 85 wRC+

The arrow pointed up for Beltre after a powerful 2024 Dominican Summer League debut. But his aggressive approach faltered stateside in 2025, where he posted chase and miss rates above 25%. He posted a .683 OPS over 52 games in the FCL, and those struggles were even more magnified after the Twins promoted him to Low-A. His raw tools remain intriguing, but improved plate discipline will be key to unlocking his potential.

The 25-year-old Eeles had another solid season in the upper minors, though the Twins rankings are more crowded now after a busy trade deadline. Eeles makes strong swing decisions and plenty of contact, though he has below-average power.

Peña, who fell off the Twin’s list is similar, with contact-driven tools and on-base potential without thump.

NL CENTRAL

Cubs

Cole Mathis, 3B

• Preseason Rank: 11
• Current Rank:7
• Stats:.215/.336/.402, 3 HR, 9 2B, 0 SB, 13.3%BB, 22.7%K, 122 wRC+

Jonathon Long, 1B/OF

• Preseason Rank: 12
• Current Rank:7
• Stats:.311/.410/.492, 20 HR ,22 2B, 2 SB, 13.2%BB, 19.1%K, 107 wRC+

Angel Cepeda, SS

• Preseason Rank: 13
• Current Rank: 17
• Stats:.249/.339/.375, 8 HR, 14 2B, 27 SB, 9.2%BB, 31.4%K, 118 wRC+

A 2023 ninth-rounder, Long is the definition of a breakout player. He launched a career-high 20 homers with Triple-A Iowa and remains one of the Cubs’ better prospects despite impressive upper-level depth and a difficult profile as a righthanded-hitting first baseman. Long has an impressive blend of plate discipline and raw power, and he shows everyday upside if he can continue to refine his approach.

Mathis was limited to designated hitter duties at Low-A Myrtle Beach after undergoing Tommy John surgery. He appeared in just 29 games, but within that small sample, he displayed signs of being a mature, disciplined hitter. Though the injury slowed his progress, Mathis remains a name to watch as he returns to full strength.

Cepeda had a solid first year in affiliate ball, showing defensive versatility and athleticism, but the bat will need to take a step forward.

Reds

Sheng-En Lin, 3B/RHP

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank:17
• Hitting Stats:.172/.348/.310, 2 HR, 4 2B, 1 SB, 21.2%BB, 26.5%K, 81 wRC+
• Pitching Stats:3.06 ERA, 47 IP, 12 GS, 61 SO, 15 BB, 7.8%BB, 31.8%K, 37%GB, 3.88 FIP

Connor Phillips, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 22
• Current Rank: 22
• Stats:2.84 ERA, 38.0 IP, 0 GS, 42 SO, 23 BB, 14.5%BB, 27.5%K, 39.5%GB, 4.53 FIP (MiLB)

Jirvin Morillo, C

• Preseason Rank:25
• Current Rank:29
• Stats:.259/.381/.431, 4 HR, 8 2B, 6 SB, 16.5%BB, 18%K, 112 wRC+

Lin showed promise at the plate over the past two years, but 2025 marked his first real test as a two-way player. On the mound, he impressed in his U.S. pro debut, flashing potential in limited innings. Offensively, though, his production dipped over 39 games in the ACL. While the sample is small, the Reds may eventually need to decide if focusing on one path will better support his long-term development.

Phillips, meanwhile, pitched his way to the majors and has been a reliable arm outside a four-run blip early in the season. He’ll likely graduate early next year.

Morillo stood out at the plate for his frequent hard contact and mature approach. Defensively, he displayed a lively arm, two-way upside and a projectable frame. While his receiving and blocking are still developing, the foundational tools are evident.

Brewers

Josh Knoth, RHP

• Preseason Rank:15
• Current Rank: 27
• Stats:Did not play

Braylon Payne, OF

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank: 11
• Stats:.240/.354/.382, 8 HR, 9 2B, 31 SB, 15.2%BB, 30.1%K, 113 wRC+

Bryce Meccage, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 20
• Current Rank: 22
• Stats:4.35 ERA, 70.1 IP, 19 GS, 69 SO, 26 BB, 8.9%BB, 23.6%K, 33.5%GB, 3.67 FIP

Payne was the 18th pick in the 2024 draft and got off to a fast start in 2025. He hit a bump midseason, but caught fire in July before cooling off down the stretch. Payneâ€s aggressive approach can lead to inconsistency, but when heâ€s on, he drives the ball with authority and impacts games offensively.

Milwaukee took Meccage, a polished prep arm, in the second round of the same draft, and he spent all of 2025 with Low-A Carolina. His fastball averaged 94 mph, and he mixed in a pair of breaking balls with 2,500 rpm of spin or better. His slider, in particular, has sharp bite and was his best swing-and-miss offering.

Knoth, another promising prep arm, he missed the season recovering from Tommy John surgery and slid to the back of the Brewers’ list.

Pirates

Jhonny Severino, SS/3B

• Preseason Rank:11
• Current Rank: 28
• Stats:.215/.277/.359, 11 HR, 24 2B, 10 SB, 6.8%BB, 25.2%K, 77 wRC+

Carlson Reed, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 16
• Current Rank:21
• Stats:4.08 ERA, 70.2 IP, 19 GS, 65 SO, 53 BB, 17.3%BB, 21.2%K, 43.6%GB, 5.05 FIP

Khristian Curtis, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 20
• Current Rank:NR
• Stats:3.98 ERA, 108.2 IP, 26 GS, 116 SO, 46 BB, 9.8%BB, 24.8%K, 41.7%GB, 4.16 FIP

Severino generated plenty of internal optimism entering the season after he mashed to a .918 OPS in the FCL in 2024, but the 20-year-old struggled mightily to consistently access his impressive raw power. He fought elevated whiff rates both in and out of the zone and particularly struggled with spin and timing issues. Severino still managed 11 homers, but his plate approach remains a work in progress.

Reed entered the year looking to build on an impressive 130-strikeout showing in the lower minors in 2024, but a back injury delayed his season, and he didn’t look like the same pitcher upon returning. He’ll head to the Arizona Fall League looking to regain momentum.

Curtis is a candidate to move back onto the list after shrugging off a slow start to the year with High-A Greensboro, though his walk rate hovered around 10% for a second consecutive season.

Cardinals

Rainiel Rodriguez, C

• Preseason Rank: 11
• Current Rank: 3
• Stats:.276/.399/.555, 20 HR, 22 2B, 4 SB, 14.7%BB, 17.7%K, 162 wRC+

Branneli Franco, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank:NR
• Stats:3.31 ERA, 16.1 IP, 2 GS, 16 SO, 5 BB, 7.1%BB, 22.9%K, 51.2%GB, 3.91 FIP

Nelfy Ynfante, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 21
• Current:NR
• Stats:4.60 ERA, 90.0 IP, 13 GS, 83 SO, 44 BB, 10.8%BB, 20.3%K, 43.5%GB, 4.42 FIP

Rodriguez made a massive statement in 2025. The catcher dominated the Florida Complex League over 20 games before earning a promotion to Low-A. His production didnâ€t miss a beat, and he capped off the year with an impressive jump to High-A—all before turning 19 years old. Rodriguezâ€s profile is especially intriguing. Despite an aggressive approach and high chase rate, heâ€s remained remarkably consistent at the plate. That ability to do damage while still refining his approach makes him one of the most exciting young hitters in the system.

Franco logged only 16 innings during his second stint in the Dominican Summer League but still earned DSL All-Star honors, flashing upside despite limited action. Both he and Ynfante slipped off the back half of the Cardinals’ list.

AL EAST

Orioles

Keeler Morfe, RHP

• Preseason Rank:14
• Current Rank: 30
• Stats:7.48 ERA, 21.2 IP, 10 GS, 24 SO, 32 BB, 27.1%BB, 20.3%K, 46.0%GB, 6.34 FIP

Thomas Sosa, OF

• Preseason Rank: 22
• Current Rank:NR
• .Stats:221/.308/.398, 9 HR, 10 2B, 4 SB, 9.1%BB, 24.7%K, 109 wRC+

An injured right ring finger delayed Morfe’s season by three months, and the Venezuelan righthander looked rusty upon his return. The 5-foot-8 righty has a 70-grade fastball that averaged nearly 99 mph this year, but scattershot command led to more walks than strikeouts, raising concerns about his overall control.

Sosa also battled injuries, missing all of April and most of May before returning to action in June. While his exit velocities remained strong, his plate discipline regressed after showing encouraging progress in 2024. Heâ€ll look to regain form and reps in the Arizona Fall League.

Red Sox

Juan Valera, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 14
• Current rank: 9
• Stats:5.45 ERA, 38 IP, 10 GS, 24 SO, 32 BB, 6%BB, 27.5%K, 38.3%GB, 3.97 FIP

Payton Tolle, LHP

• Preseason Rank: 15
• Current rank: 2
• Stats:3.04 ERA, 91.2 IP, 18 GS, 133 SO, 23 BB, 6.3%BB, 36.5%K, 37%GB, 2.75 FIP (MiLB)

Nelly Taylor, OF

• Preseason Rank: 23
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:.216/.355/.349, 7 HR, 24 2B, 29 SB, 8.4%BB, 31.9%K, 113 wRC+

Tolle was a massive breakout. He established himself as one of the minors’ most intriguing arms before the Red Sox called him up to aid their playoff push in his first full pro season. Tolle combines deception, angle and intent to consistently miss bats. His low three-quarters slot and long extension create a tough look, with his fastball jumping on hitters and playing above its velocity. Tolle pairs it with a developing mix of secondaries, and he has shown improved sequencing since shifting his focus to pitching full time after he was a two-way player in college.

Valera showed advanced feel and mound presence in his stateside debut, flashing average or better command across two levels. While he wasnâ€t as overpowering as he was in 2024, his 46-to-10 K/BB ratio reflects his polish and pitchability, even as contact ticked up.

Taylorâ€s bat remains a work in progress—he struck out 133 times—but he still impacts the baseball when he connects, hinting at offensive upside.

Yankees

Cam Schlittler, RHP

• Preseason Rank:15
• Current Rank: 2
• Stats:2.82 ERA, 76.2 IP, 14 GS, 99 SO, 26 BB, 8.4%BB, 31.9%K, 47.8%GB, 2.51 FIP (MiLB)

Carlos Lagrange, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 16
• Current Rank: 4
• Stats:3.52 ERA, 120 IP, 23 GS, 168 SO, 62 BB,  12.3%BB, 36.5%K, 40%GB, 3.14 FIPÂ

Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank: 5
• Stats:2.38 ERA, 140 IP, 24 GS, 166 SO, 62 BB, 9.6%BB, 29.5%K, 55.6%GB, 2.46 FIP

The Yankees breakout group stands out, led by Schlittler, who forced his way to the big leagues after his stuff took a clear step forward. Schlittler gained two mph on his fastball in the minors compared to 2024, and he’s throwing it even harder in the majors, where he’s averaging 97.9 mph. Schlittler dominated the upper minors and owns a 3.05 ERA through 11 big league starts.

Lagrange has premium velocity and recently touched 103 mph in a start, but he has long battled control issues. He’s repeating his delivery better and throwing more strikes in 2025, though his walk rates are still fringy for a starter. He could be on the verge of a major breakthrough in 2026 if he can continue to throw more strikes.

Rodriguez-Cruz, meanwhile, is right on his tail and closing strong. The righthander, who came over from the Red Sox in the Carlos Narvaez trade and has been a mainstay on the Hot Sheet this season, has 74 strikeouts and a 2.64 ERA in 61.1 innings since his promotion to Double-A in July.

Rays

Emilien Pitre, 2B

• Preseason Rank:14
• Current Rank:22
• Stats:.268/.356/.393, 9 HR, 23 2B, 14 SB, 11.6%BB, 20.4%K, 121 wRC+

Yoniel Curet, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 17
• Current Rank: 8
• Stats:3.63 ERA, 52 IP, 14 GS, 56 SO, 30 BB, 13.2%BB, 24.6%K, 38.6%GB, 4.00 FIP

Homer Bush Jr., OF

• Preseason Rank:20
• Current Rank:23
• Stats:.295/.371/.347, 0 HR, 12 2B, 57 SB, 9%BB, 18.1%K, 118 wRC+

A right shoulder injury delayed Curet’s season debut by nearly three months, but since returning, he has quickly established himself as one of the most promising pitchers in a system known for producing elite arms. His 96 mph fastball is one of the better heaters in the minors and generated whiffs roughly 30% of the time this year.

Bush is a dynamic baserunner with elite speed who stole 57 bases this season. Reducing strikeouts would help him become an even more consistent threat on the bases, and there’s more underlying power in his profile than his zero home runs might suggest.

Pitreâ€s calling card is his outstanding defense, as his range and glove work stand out at every level. However, to make a significant impact in the pros, he needs to improve offensively. He showed a bit more power as the season progressed. If he can fine tune his plate discipline and improve his pitch recognition, he could raise his overall profile.

Blue Jays

Khal Stephen, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 11
• Current Rank: 6 (Guardians)
• Stats:2.55 ERA, 99 IP, 20 GS, 107 SO, 19 BB, 4.9%BB, 27.4%K, 20.6%GB, 2.60 FIPÂ

R.J. Schreck, OF

• Preseason Rank: 14
• Current Rank:12
• Stats:.256/.396/.481, 18 HR, 13 2B, 9 SB, 15.6%BB, 21.2%K, 147 wRC+

Sean Keys, 3B

• Preseason Rank:23
• Current Rank: 28
• Stats:.217/.365/.408, 19 HR, 22 2B, 8 SB, 16.3%BB, 22.1%K, 118 wRC+

Stephen was one of the systemâ€s fastest risers before the Guardians acquired him in the Shane Bieber trade. He impressed with an advanced feel for sequencing, sharp command and the ability to work deep into outings with minimal traffic. His knack for missing bats without giving away free passes made him a reliable, efficient presence on the mound and a clear candidate for rotation work at the next level.

Schreck continues to profile as a disciplined lefthanded bat with sneaky power. He does an excellent job controlling the zone and rarely chases, allowing his natural strength to play. He could become a second-division regular who can handle all three outfield spots.

Keys brings big raw power from the left side, but his approach remains a work in progress. While the swing-and-miss has been an issue, heâ€s shown a surprisingly advanced eye at the plate. If the hit tool can catch up, there’s everyday upside in the bat—especially if the power continues to translate.

NL EAST

Braves

Didier Fuentes, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 11
• Current Rank:4
• Stats:4.58 ERA, 57 IP, 13 GS, 71 SO, 16 BB, 6.7%BB, 17.4%K, 35%GB, 2.89 FIPÂ

John Gil, SS

• Preseason Rank: 12
• Current Rank:15
• Stats:.254/.349/.371, 7 HR, 25 2B, 51 SB, 12.4%BB, 14.1%K, 115 wRC+

Davis Polo, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 19
• Current Rank: 24
• Stats:Did not play

Fuentes’ progress impressed the shorthanded Braves enough to warrant a big league callup at just 20 years old. He has a strong command of the strike zone and posted a 29.8% strikeout rate across three levels of the minors, though he missed fewer bats in his brief big league showing. Fuentes was the subject of a recent Statcast Standouts deep dive, as well.

Gil has an interesting combination of power, speed and the ability to control the strike zone. He could become a solid offensive contributor in time. Polo, meanwhile, did not play this season because of an unspecified injury.

Marlins

Andres Valor, OF

• Preseason Rank:15
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats: .231/.335/.372, 9 HR, 22 2B, 45 SB, 11.0%BB, 29.0%K, 105 wRC+

Jose Paulino, RHP

• Preseason Rank: 16
• Current Rank: 18
• Stats:4.70 ERA, 38.1 IP, 12 GS, 56 SO, 20 BB, 11.8%BB, 32.9%K, 49.3%GB, 3.07 FIPÂ

Abrahan Ramirez, 2B

• Preseason Rank: 18
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:.238/.372/.302, 0 HR, 19 2B, 14 SB, 16.9%BB, 21.3%K, 105 wRC+

Valor shows flashes of power and speed, but his strikeout rate remains a concern, even if he offsets it with solid plate discipline and strong walk rates. A combination of muted production and struggles against righthanded pitching dropped him off the Marlins’ list.

Paulino has shown promise on the mound with good strikeout ability and solid groundball rates. While his ERA is slightly above average, his FIP suggests he has been a bit unlucky. His control has room for improvement, but his stuff has been effective, overall. Paulino is trending toward becoming a reliable rotation piece with continued development in his command.

Ramirez has solid on-base ability with minimal over-the-fence power so far. Like Valor, he fell off the Marlins’ list.

Mets

Boston Baro, SS/3B

• Preseason Rank: 14
• Current Rank: 13
• Stats:.224/.282/.321, 4 HR, 16 2B, 28 SB, 7.2%BB, 20.3%K, 85 wRC+

Jonathan Santucci, LHP

• Preseason Rank: 15
• Current Rank: 12
• Stats:3.06 ERA, 117.2 IP, 23 GS, 138 SO, 41 BB, 8.5%BB, 28.7%K, 47.2%GB, 2.98 FIPÂ

Christopher Suero, C/OF

• Preseason Rank: 19
• Current Rank: 17
• Stats:.232/.380/.411, 16 HR, 16 2B, 34 SB, 14.9%BB, 18.9%K, 142 wRC+

The Mets had plenty of offensive players take steps forward this year, but Baro had a challenging season in which he struggled to hit for much impact. Defensively, he offers flexibility with his ability to play both shortstop and third base, but his offensive development will need to catch up for him to fulfill his potential.

Santucci has been solid on the mound, with impressive strikeout numbers and good control. His ERA and FIP both reflect his strong performance, and his ability to generate ground balls has helped him manage contact effectively. With a consistent strikeout rate and limited walks, Santucci looks to be on track to continue as a reliable starting pitcher with a high floor.

Suero has been one of the Mets’ more intriguing hitters. He has an impressive power-speed combination for an unusual defensive profile.

Phillies

Devin Saltiban, 2B

• Preseason Rank: 11
• Current Rank: 12
• Stats:.180/.259/.305, 7 HR, 11 2B, 19 SB, 6.7%BB, 29.9%K, 72 wRC+

Alex McFarlane, RHP

• Preseason Rank:19
• Current Rank: 17
• Stats:4.67 ERA, 79 IP, 18 GS, 80 SO, 42 BB, 12.4%BB, 23.5%K, 39.6%GB, 3.80 FIPÂ

Alirio Ferrebus, C

• Preseason Rank: 20
• Current Rank:21
• Stats:.236/.308/.348, 5 HR, 11 2B, 2 SB, 6.1%BB, 16.1%K, 85 wRC+

Injuries wiped out most of Saltiban’s first half, and he struggled to get on track once he settled in. His willingness to chase led to elevated strikeout totals and limited his impact. He’ll need to improve his approach to become a more reliable contributor offensively, though his speed remains an asset.

McFarlaneâ€s performance has been solid but unspectacular. While heâ€s struggled with walks, his strikeout rate is decent, and he did a solid job limiting damage. His FIP suggests his ERA may improve with better luck, but his command will be key for his continued development as a potential rotation piece.

Ferrebus has provided solid defense behind the plate, but offensively, heâ€s been inconsistent. His power has been modest, and his low walk rate limits his on-base opportunities. Ferrebus will need to refine his offensive game to maximize his overall value.

Nationals

Jake Bennett, LHP

• Preseason Rank: 13
• Current Rank: 15
• Stats:2.43 ERA, 70.1 IP, 18GS, 61 SO, 19 BB, 6.7%BB, 21.6%K, 39.6%GB, 3.02 FIPÂ

Angel Feliz, SS

• Preseason Rank:15
• Current Rank:16
• Stats:.253/.346/.362, 4 HR, 10 2B, 15 SB, 12.2%BB, 20.6%K, 105 wRC+

Andrew Pinckney, OF

• Preseason Rank: 16
• Current Rank: NR
• Stats:.269/.348/.431, 20 HR, 9 2B, 34 SB, 8.6%BB, 29.1%K, 109 wRC+

Bennett has had an excellent season, showing strong control and the ability to generate plenty of ground balls. His strikeout rate isnâ€t overpowering, but his overall ability to limit traffic, walks and keep the ball in the park makes him a strong candidate for a reliable rotation spot.

Feliz has been a steady performer this season, showcasing his ability to get on base and contribute in multiple areas. Heâ€s been solid in terms of both power and speed, and his plate discipline has helped him. While his strikeout rate is slightly elevated, Feliz remains a solid option at shortstop with a well-rounded offensive game.

On the surface, Pinckney delivered a strong season of power and speed in the upper minors, but his strikeouts are a concern. As such, he went from middle of the pack among the Nationals’ top 30 to off the list completely.

Source link