Mets trying to get to bottom of Ryan Helsley's struggles after blown save against Phillies

Ryan Helsley's time in Flushing has been anything but successful for the All-Star closer.

Since the Mets acquired him from the Cardinals at the trade deadline, Helsley has pitched to a 0-3 record and a 10.38 ERA — thanks to 14 runs (10 earned) in 8.2 innings pitched. In four save opportunities, Helsley has blown each one, including Tuesday's eventual 6-5 win over the Philadelphia Phillies.

With a 5-3 lead, manager Carlos Mendoza called on Helsley to hold the lead for closer Edwin Diaz. It's the first save opportunity Helsley has had since Aug. 15 against the Mariners. In three appearances (3 IP) between outings, Helsley has allowed three runs — all coming from one appearance. The veteran right-hander had pitched in a low-leverage situation in Monday's series opener against the Phillies, striking out one in a 1-2-3 frame.

Helsley would have the opposite outing, giving up a two-run shot with one out to Harrison Bader to give up the lead. After a walk, Mendoza had no choice but to remove Helsley for Diaz, who got five outs to pick up the win thanks to Brandon Nimmo's walk-off single in the ninth.

Diaz was asked about his cohort in the bullpen and if he could relate to his struggles. The Mets closer knows struggles all too well, as he had a rollercoaster season in 2024 before rounding into his 2022 dominant form by the end of the year. And because of that, he trusts Helsley to figure it out.

"I've been through that. My advice to him is just, stay with your head up. We trust him," Diaz said after Tuesday's game. "We know what pitcher he is. He's one of the best closers in the game. He's going through some bad moments right now but we trust in him and we support him. Just stay with your head up and we keep going."

Just last year, Helsley led MLB with 49 saves in 53 opportunities with a 2.04 ERA. So that dominance is in there and the Mets know it, they are still trying to navigate these struggles.

Helsley intimated in the past that he's still adjusting to his new role with the Mets, but Mendoza hinted that it could be something else. Is Helsley tipping his pitches? Some games, it feels like it and the Mets are trying to get to the bottom of it.

"Too good of a stuff for them to be taking some really good swings on fastballs, get really good takes on sliders. We got to look back and see what we’re missing," Mendoza said of Helsley. "For teams to have comfortable at-bats like that, something is going on here. We have to figure it out."

After appearing in back-to-back games, Helsley is likely unavailable in Wednesday's series finale with the Phillies, so the right-hander will have to wait until the Marlins series to show that he can be the bridge to Diaz that the Mets traded for.