Isles’ Matthew Schaefer edges Crosby as youngest with OT goal

Nov 15, 2025, 02:49 AM ET

SALT LAKE CITY — Matthew Schaefer scored on a slap shot 2:08 into overtime to become the youngest player to score an overtime goal in a regular-season NHL game as the New York Islanders beat the Utah Mammoth 3-2 on Friday night for their third straight extra-time victory.

Jonathan Drouin and Emil Heineman also scored for the Islanders (10-6-2) in their fourth straight win. David Rittich stopped 27 shots, including all 16 after the first period.

Schaefer, the defenseman selected first overall in this year’s NHL draft, has 15 points, most among NHL rookies. He is 18 years, 70 days old, younger than Sidney Crosby, who was 18 years, 101 days when he scored an overtime goal on Nov. 16, 2005.

Editor’s Picks

• 

Dylan Guenther and JJ Peterka scored for the Mammoth in the Utah franchise’s 100th game. Karel Vejmelka had 19 saves.

The Mammoth are the best in the NHL in limiting shots on goal, and they outshot the Islanders 29-21 as they dropped to 5-1-1 at home.

New York tied it 2-2 with 6:16 remaining when the puck went off Drouin’s skate and was touched by Utah defenseman Nate Schmidt’s stick as it passed over the goal line. The goal was initially disallowed but reversed after video review.

At 18 years, 70 days old, Islanders rookie Matthew Schaefer broke Sidney Crosby’s record as the youngest player to score an overtime goal in a regular-season game. Aaron Baker/Icon Sportswire

Heineman opened the scoring 7:13 into the first period — the second straight contest he notched the first goal of the game.

Peterka tied it with just under 7 minutes remaining in the first with his sixth of the season.

The Mammoth ended their seven-game power-play goal drought when Guenther’s slap shot went over Rittich’s shoulder during a 5-on-3 with 1:25 left in the opening period to take a 2-1 lead. That marked the first time this season the Islanders gave up a goal with a two-man disadvantage.

The Islanders beat the Vegas Golden Knights in overtime Thursday and was in the second half of a back-to-back but matched the Mammoth’s energy with rugged defense and deft power-play kills, squelching 5 of 6 opportunities.

Source link