RoboScout’s Top Hitting, Pitching Fantasy Prospects For 2025

Ahh, the autumnal equinox…one of RoboScoutâ€s top two equinoxes. With Triple-A regular season games wrapping up today, another minor league baseball season is almost over. RoboScout can finally power down his processors, but not before this weekâ€s minor league season retrospective of the top 75 hitters by peak projections and top 50 pitchers by peak projections.

Over the coming weeks, we will have additional robo-content coming out: underrated hitters and pitchers per RoboScout, plus minor league HIT+ and “Stuff†leaders and plenty more.

Top 75 Hitters With Peak Projections

Below are the top 75 hitters per RoboScout along with estimated peak projections based on their 2025 minor league performance.

The basic methodology for how the list was made can be found in our midseason top prospects per RoboScout here and is based on expected fantasy production.

ranknameorglvlxbaxobpwrc+hrsb1Samuel BasalloBALAAA0.2790.3651373612Kevin McGonigleDETAA0.2940.3751362973Rainiel RodriguezSTLA+0.2810.3581253734Konnor GriffinPITAA0.2770.35113024225Leo De VriesATHAA0.2830.3621272566Josue BricenoDETAA0.2750.3571263017Bryce EldridgeSFGAAA0.2620.3371153328Lazaro MontesSEAAA0.2560.3391193239Dylan BeaversBALAAA0.2670.351121221810Luis PenaMILA+0.2750.341112212211Sebastian WalcottTEXAA0.2740.353116221612Jesus MadeMILAA0.2720.349121171713Ryan CliffordNYMAAA0.2690.34911236414Colt EmersonSEAAAA0.2850.35811622515Owen CaissieCHCAAA0.2510.33311925416Justin CrawfordPHIAAA0.2710.346118133017Eduardo QuinteroLADA+0.2680.349120251818Sal StewartCINAAA0.2820.350115251019Edward FlorentinoPITA0.2680.345118292120Max ClarkDETAA0.2780.36212321921Walker JenkinsMINAAA0.2700.348112211322Jordan LawlarARIAAA0.2550.332113212123Eduardo TaitMINA+0.2650.33010625224Spencer JonesNYYAAA0.2380.313107331725Cole YoungSEAAAA0.2790.35411516626Nelson RadaLAAAAA0.2810.358112132627Moises BallesterosCHCAAA0.2780.34811617428Justin GonzalesBOSA+0.2770.34511217729Jett WilliamsNYMAAA0.2690.346113211730Michael ArroyoSEAAA0.2700.34611620631Rece HindsCINAAA0.2440.312111261632Harry FordSEAAAA0.2620.34511320633Nathan FlewellingTBRA+0.2550.34411019434Jacob ReimerNYMAA0.2640.33811922735JJ WetherholtSTLAAA0.2680.346112201436Dax KilbyNYYA0.2720.348107143637Luke AdamsMILAA0.2630.34611521938Caleb BonemerCHWA+0.2660.345115211239Esmerlyn ValdezPITAA0.2600.33512025240Aidan MillerPHIAAA0.2670.347106203041Carter JensenKCRAAA0.2660.34010823642Josue De PaulaLADAA0.2690.355121201643Hendry MendezMINAA0.2800.35711816644Nate GeorgeBALA+0.2650.334108152545Adael AmadorCOLAAA0.2690.343107171846Brice MatthewsHOUAAA0.2380.318105212647Gabriel GonzalezMINAAA0.2730.33911019548Jacob MeltonHOUAAA0.2490.327107202349Ryan RitterCOLAAA0.2510.32710923550Ralphy VelazquezCLEAA0.2680.33911623151Ryan WardLADAAA0.2500.32410927952Victor Mesa Jr.MIAAAA0.2590.32710721853George Lombard Jr.NYYAA0.2540.335108161654Juneiker CaceresCLEA0.2820.35311319655Hector RodriguezCINAAA0.2710.33310223856Cooper HummelTBRAAA0.2460.33111628557Aron EstradaBALAA0.2690.340113161758Jeral PerezCHWA+0.2550.31910030559Alfredo DunoCINA0.2800.36612628260A.J. EwingNYMAA0.2660.339114112661Xavier IsaacTBRAA0.2450.33410726362Kendall GeorgeLADA+0.2660.34310194863Cooper PrattMILAA0.2700.344105151764Braylon PayneMILA0.2440.324100232065Roldy BritoCOLA0.2700.339115161966Jonathon LongCHCAAA0.2570.33311018267Emmanuel RodriguezMINAAA0.2370.332106171468Luis LaraMILAA0.2710.34910892069Eli WillitsWSHA0.2660.34010617970Jose FerminSTLAAA0.2690.344111122271William BergollaCHWAA0.2900.34910772172Joe MackMIAAAA0.2400.31110124773Franklin AriasBOSAA0.2790.34311016574Chris SueroNYMAA0.2430.325108231775Jefferson RojasCHCAA0.2640.3371061810

Some interesting names include two FYPD players: Yankees shortstop Dax Kilby at No. 36 and Nationals shortstop Eli Willits at No. 69.

Even after an extremely disappointing season, Twins outfielder Emmanuel Rodriguez is still in the Top 70.

Top 50 Pitchers With Peak Projections

Below are the top 50 pitchers per RoboScout along with their peak projections, based solely on minor league performance – with, as will be briefly discussed below, no knowledge about the pitcherâ€s health status (or their major league performance, if any).

ranknameorglvlk%bb%gb%xeraxwhip1Jonah TongNYMAAA31%7%54%2.951.072Chase BurnsCINAAA27%5%45%3.181.053Robby SnellingMIAAAA24%5%52%3.181.114Thomas WhiteMIAAAA31%8%42%3.391.105Payton TolleBOSAAA26%6%45%3.551.106Didier FuentesATLAAA24%5%44%3.561.127Jack PerkinsATHAAA30%8%44%3.721.128Elmer Rodriguez-CruzNYYAAA23%6%56%3.421.189Trey YesavageTORAAA28%7%40%3.631.1110Jacob MisiorowskiMILAAA27%7%44%3.661.1611Mick AbelMINAAA24%7%49%3.641.1812Troy MeltonDETAAA25%6%41%3.621.1313Logan HendersonMILAAA24%6%41%3.751.1514Cristian MenaARIAAA24%6%47%3.801.1515Joe BoyleTBRAAA26%8%50%3.611.2016Connelly EarlyBOSAAA25%7%51%3.631.1917Travis SykoraWSHA+27%8%46%3.581.1618Cam SchlittlerNYYAAA25%7%49%3.621.1919David FestaMINAAA25%6%45%3.711.1520Ian SeymourTBRAAA23%6%39%3.961.1721Tekoah RobySTLAAA22%6%46%3.851.1922Jacob LopezATHAAA27%7%43%3.881.1523Nolan McLeanNYMAAA23%7%54%3.731.2324Sean Paul LinanWSHAAA23%7%47%3.981.2025Parker MessickCLEAAA23%7%46%3.811.2226Mitch BrattARIAA22%4%42%3.701.1327Yordanny MonegroBOSAA25%7%53%3.371.1728Jarlin SusanaWSHAA28%9%49%3.561.1929Coleman CrowMILAAA25%6%49%3.551.1530AJ Smith-ShawverATLAAA23%7%46%3.931.2031Brandon YoungBALAAA21%6%46%4.061.2332Brandon WalterHOUAAA22%6%54%3.851.2033Santiago SuarezTBRAAA19%5%44%4.121.2234Ty JohnsonTBRAA25%8%40%3.771.2035Ethan PeckoHOUAAA23%6%42%4.011.1936Trey GibsonBALAAA22%7%49%3.781.2237Michael ForretBALAA23%7%43%3.821.2138JR RitchieATLAAA20%7%53%3.971.2839Andrew PainterPHIAAA20%6%44%4.041.2440Mike BurrowsPITAAA25%7%42%3.981.1941Caden ScarboroughTEXA+22%6%45%3.721.2042Hunter BarcoPITAA23%8%47%4.081.2543Wei-En LinATHA+24%7%44%3.821.1944David ShieldsKCRA21%5%47%3.591.1945Braxton AshcraftPITAAA21%7%49%4.001.2646Jose CorniellTEXAAA22%6%46%4.021.1847David DavalilloTEXAA21%6%51%3.811.2348Blade TidwellSFGAAA21%7%44%4.091.2349Braxton BraggBALAA23%7%48%3.791.2450Johnny KingTORA27%9%45%3.711.21

There are a number of pitchers on this list who are currently injured, including some who have undergone Tommy John surgery and will miss most, if not all, of 2026: Orioles RHP Braxton Bragg, Braves RHP AJ Smith-Shawver, Red Sox RHP Yordanny Monegro, Cardinals RHP Tekoah Roby and Nationals RHP Travis Sykora. Others, such as Nationals right hander Jarlin Susana are shut down with other injuries, of various severity. Adjust accordingly based on this information.

The highest-ranked pitchers who have not yet debuted in the major leagues are a pair of Marlins. Both Robby Snelling and Thomas White ended the year in Triple-A and project at peak to have sub-3.50 ERAs.

For the final time this year, happy bidding!

Source link